The plea

Alright so time is up!

There were four submissions into the contest, Here are my foot notes for each deck

Wagnerl

Originality: 4.5/10
Effectiveness:7/10
Mechanics:7.5/10
Consistency:6/10

-Lost Originality points for a Fairly Typical Earth/Air Deck
-Got Originaltiy points for Using Kolmo + Citadel Lodestone'
-Lost Some Effectiveness points for not fully maxxing out Taffial's Ability, by using more attack cards twice
-Looks Like it could hold its ground in a match
-Lost Mechanics points for Lots of High BP attacks and Lots of Low BP attacks, this can work against you
-Lost Consistency points for in consistant Attacks and Locations
-Gained Consistecny points for the Attacks and Location Meshing together alright

TOTAL 25/40
===================================================

Twisterx241

Originality: 7/10
Effectiveness:8/10
Mechanics:6/10
Consistency:6/10

-Lost Originality Because of of a typical Strike Deck
-Gained Originality, by placing your own spin on it
-Has a good Effectivness mark, because it could hold up really well in a fight
-Lost Mechanic points for Lack of mugic counters, you cant play All of your mugic, which can be a massive disadvantage
-Attacks and Locations mesh nicely
-Attack cards look semi-spontainious

TOTAL 27/40
===================================================

Gamemaster76

Originality: 7/10
Effectiveness:6/10
Mechanics:6.5/10
Consistency:5.5/10

-Lost originality points for Using the 2 Owayki/Prince Mundeenu COTG combo
-Gained Originality for using Ruhban, Maliph and Rasbma with the above combo
-Good effetivness mark because I know this would be good in a battle.
-Lost some Mechanics points for Sword of Khy'at, There are some better choices like the Levitaar, But the sword still works fine.
-Mugic is good a nice balance of Healing and Dealing mugic
-Lost consistency points for not doubling up in attacks and locations, this is Ok however since it adds much more variety
-Attacks and Loactions mesh togeth OK.

TOTAL 25/40
===================================================

Guilieon

Originality 8/10
Effectiveness 5/10
Mechanics 5/10
Consistancy 6.5/10

-Gained Originality for using the lesser Mipedian Strikers
-Decent effectiveness mark, It could do O.K. in a match
-Lost mechanic points for some poorer Battlegear choices
-lost mechanics points for some attack cards that probably shouldn't be there
-Attacks a Location mesh alright.

TOTAL 24.5/40


So Twister WON!


But it is not over yet... Oh nay nay. The contestants have one shot to attempt to make me improve their score. How? With the points stated above, you must try to convince me that those negative points shouldn't be there. (ie. I stated against Twister "-Lost Mechanic points for Lack of mugic counters, you cant play All of your mugic, which can be a massive disadvantage" Maybe my math was wrong.) Try to convince me to improve your score!

HOWEVER! If you point something out and it turns out that it uncovered something about your deck that would make you lose points, it will. So be careful.

You guys have until Sunday at Midnight (I'll take into consideration your time-zone)

Kerb.